# Getting Somalia Wrong? (2012), Mary Harper: iimaan, dagaal iyo rajo dowlad burburtay

> Getting Somalia Wrong? (2012) ee Mary Harper: dooddeeda ku saabsan 'dowlad fashilantay', ganacsiga iyo isgaarsiinta dowlad la'aanta, iyo sida loo qaabilay.

Source page: https://calankii.com/so/books/getting-somalia-wrong-harper/
Language: so
Translation of: https://calankii.com/en/books/getting-somalia-wrong-harper/
Last checked: 2026-11-12
Publisher: Calankii (https://calankii.com)

## Buugga

**Getting Somalia Wrong? Faith, War and Hope in a Shattered State** waxaa qortay **Mary Harper**, weriye iyo tifaftiraha Afrika ee BBC, waxaana daabacay Zed Books 2012 iyadoo qayb ka ah taxanaha African Arguments ([Powell's](https://www.powells.com/book/getting-somalia-wrong-9781842779330)). Ma aha taariikh isku xigta, balse waa cutubyo ku saabsan mawduucyo sharxaya Soomaaliya xilligaas ([African Arguments](https://africanarguments.org/2012/01/getting-somalia-wrong-faith-war-and-hope-in-a-shattered-state-a-review-by-magnus-taylor/)).

## Dooddeeda

- **Ka baxsan "dowlad fashilantay".** Harper waxay ku doodaysaa in summaddani aysan muujin waxa dhulka ka jira: dowlad dhexe la'aanteed, ganacsiga iyo siyaasadda maxalliga ah ee Soomaalidu way shaqeeyeen, xitaa way koreen ([How We Made It in Africa](https://www.howwemadeitinafrica.com/challenging-perceptions-about-somalia/19612/)).
- **Isgaarsiinta.** Waxay tusaale u soo qaadataa isgaarsiinta, oo Soomaaliya ay ka mid ahayd dalalkii hore u qaatay taleefannada gacanta ([How We Made It in Africa](https://www.howwemadeitinafrica.com/challenging-perceptions-about-somalia/19612/)). Eeg [Lacagta moobaylka](/so/economy/mobile-money/).
- **Soomaaliland.** Dib-u-eegisyadu waxay xuseen sharaxaaddeeda dib-u-heshiisiinta beelaha iyo hay'adaha la doortay ee Soomaaliland ([African Arguments](https://africanarguments.org/2012/02/getting-somalia-wrong-signs-of-hope-in-a-shattered-state-a-realistic-but-empathetic-analysis-review-by-keith-somerville/)).
- **Amniga.** Daabacaha ayaa sheegay inay ku doodayso in Soomaaliya loo eego al-Qaacida oo keliya ay sii xasillooni-darro gelin karto Soomaaliya iyo Geeska Afrika ([Powell's](https://www.powells.com/book/getting-somalia-wrong-9781842779330)).

## Sida loo qaabilay

Keith Somerville (African Arguments) wuxuu ku tilmaamay "falanqayn xaqiiqo ah oo naxariis leh" ([African Arguments](https://africanarguments.org/2012/02/getting-somalia-wrong-signs-of-hope-in-a-shattered-state-a-realistic-but-empathetic-analysis-review-by-keith-somerville/)). Dib-u-eegis Peace News ah ayaa sheegtay in Harper aysan ka hadlin taageeradii Mareykanku siiyay dowladdii Siyaad Barre 1980-yadii ([Peace News](https://peacenews.info/node/7076)).

## Halka laga akhriyo

- Nuqul la amaahdo: [Internet Archive](https://archive.org/details/gettingsomaliawr0000harp)
- Maktabadaha: [WorldCat](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=Getting+Somalia+Wrong+Harper)